Search this site
173 results found with an empty search
- Control System Migrations | Procurement Specification & Vendor Selection
Introduction | Control System Migrations | Part 3 October 2024 — by Tom McGreevy, PE, PMP, CFSE — If you’ve made it through justifying the cost for your control system migration project and mitigating risks through front-end loading (FEL) , you are probably well aware that control system migrations are complex projects that require careful planning and strategic decision-making to ensure a successful outcome. Whether upgrading legacy systems or implementing new technology, organizations are faced with several choices throughout the migration process. From deciding whether to handle tasks internally or outsource them, to selecting the right vendor(s) and structuring procurement, each decision plays a vital role in the overall success of the project. In part three of our control system migration series , we take a look at procurement specification and vendor selection considerations such as the make-or-buy decision, specification development, comparing bids, managing purchase orders, and selecting between an OEM or systems integrator. This blog will help operators navigate the challenges of control system migrations and make informed decisions that align with their project goals, budget, and long-term operational needs. To Make or To Buy — That is the Question One of the biggest questions that operators must ask themselves during any control system migration project is whether to perform key tasks internally (" make ") or to outsource them to external engineering firms (" buy "). This decision impacts not only the project’s cost structure but also the timeline, resource allocation, and overall risk management. In-House Expertise vs. External Support The first question any organization must ask is whether they have the internal expertise to first develop the necessary procurement specifications, and later to perform critical tasks like hardware and software configuration, testing, construction or construction oversight, and finally commissioning and startup. If a company has a seasoned in-house team with experience in these areas, then it might make sense to handle much of the work internally. However, the reality for many organizations is that, while in the past they may have had this level of specialization in-house, years of corporate downsizing has resulted in a plant that is staffed to operate and maintain, but not to change or grow. This is where external partners can offer value. Developing Functional and Hardware Specifications Many clients seeking to replace or upgrade their control systems find that developing detailed functional specifications and hardware requirements is one of the most daunting challenges. It has become more common for organizations to partner with engineering firms like aeSolutions to provide these services, ensuring that the right foundation is set for successful vendor engagement and implementation. Whether you decide to develop specifications internally or bring in external help largely depends on your team’s capacity to handle such detail-oriented work in the time required to complete it. Project Scope and Complexity Projects that involve complex control system migrations, especially those operating in regulated or highly specialized industries, often benefit from third-party expertise to manage risk. The make-or-buy decision can also hinge on how familiar your internal team is with new technology or compliance requirements. Resource Allocation and Timeline Time is a critical factor. Even if you have the expertise to, for instance, develop the specifications internally, does your team have the bandwidth to dedicate to such a significant task? External vendors can accelerate this process, as they often have pre-existing frameworks, tools, and processes to expedite specification development, procurement planning, and system integration. The decision to "make or buy" in a control system migration project is multifaceted, involving an assessment of internal capabilities, the scope of the project, and the available resources. Partnering with an external engineering firm can significantly help operators navigate these decisions by offering specialized services in functional specification development, hardware design, and project management. For companies without the necessary in-house resources, opting for external support can ensure that projects stay on time and within budget, while minimizing risk and ensuring compliance with industry standards. The Importance of an Apples-to-Apples Comparison of Bids If you’ve decided to work with an external vendor for your control system migrations project, you’ll need to be prepared to solicit and compare bids. The process of comparing these bids can become complex if the requirements are not clearly defined or standardized across vendors. The key to a fair comparison is ensuring that the procurement specifications are well-documented, precise, and conveyed in a way that all bidders understand and respond to similarly. Establishing Clear and Consistent Requirements A well-defined procurement specification is essential to level the playing field for all potential vendors. The goal here is to outline your system’s requirements in enough detail so that bidders know exactly what you need. Even if every detail isn't fully defined at the outset, sharing a clear overview of the project's scope and expectations can prevent wide variations in vendor proposals. If the procurement specifications are vague or too open-ended, you may end up receiving a wide range of responses — from proposals that only cover the absolute bare minimum to others that offer high-end, premium solutions that far exceed the project’s actual needs. This spectrum of responses can make it challenging to make an apples-to-apples comparison of the bids and determine which one offers the best value for your organization. Balancing Price and Value Without precise specifications, vendors may interpret your project needs differently, leading to bids that range from cost-effective solutions to more feature-rich — and more expensive — options. For instance, one bidder might propose the minimum viable solution to meet basic operational requirements, while another might propose an advanced system that exceeds your actual needs. The challenge lies in striking a balance between affordability and value. While the lowest bid may seem attractive from a budgetary perspective, it may not meet all the functional requirements. Conversely, the highest bid may offer unnecessary features that inflate the overall cost. By defining the requirements clearly from the start, you can ensure that all vendors are bidding on the same or a very similar scope, which in turn allows you to make a fair comparison. The process of comparing bids is more than just identifying the lowest price — it's about ensuring that the bids align with the project's requirements and offer the best value. By taking the time to develop a detailed procurement specification, you can help ensure that all vendors are bidding on the same scope, enabling a fair and effective comparison. This ultimately helps reduce the risk of selecting a solution that either underperforms or overextends your budget without adding proportional value. One Purchase Order or Several? When planning a control system migration, contracting strategy is an area that can significantly impact project execution, specifically, whether to issue one purchase order covering all aspects of the project or to break it down into several purchase orders, each targeting specific phases or services. This decision is largely influenced by how much control an organization wants over individual project elements and the resources available for managing multiple contractors or vendors. In recent years, it has become more common for clients to solicit bids that cover the entire project scope — functional specification, configuration, construction, and testing — under one proposal. This trend is driven by a desire to reduce management complexity and place responsibility on a single contractor, who may either perform all the work or manage subcontractors on behalf of the client. Choosing to issue a single purchase order means entrusting a single entity with managing the entire project, from developing the functional requirements specification to system configuration, construction, and even system testing. This centralized approach can streamline communication and coordination, as one vendor takes responsibility for delivering the full scope of the project. This option can reduce the burden on the operator/project manager(s), who won't need to oversee multiple contractors or manage complex interdependencies between different service providers. It is likely that most bidders responding to a “one purchase order” solicitation will themselves have to partner with others to bring the full set of skills needed. For instance, it is a rare systems integrator who is also a fully qualified electrical contractor and has its own craft labor, so the SI may have to sub-contract the construction and perform a construction management role. In these circumstances, the ability of the bidding “prime” contactor to manage sub-contractors should be fully investigated. Alternatively, opting for several purchase orders allows the client to maintain more direct control over each phase of the project. For example, one organization might handle the functional specification, another would take care of configuration, a separate electrical contractor could be hired for construction, and yet another vendor could handle system fabrication and testing. By compartmentalizing the work across multiple vendors, the client can select specialists for each task, potentially increasing the quality of each deliverable. However, this approach demands more from the client in terms of project management and coordination, as they will need to ensure seamless handoffs between each contractor and resolve any issues that arise between different teams. Benefits of a Single Purchase Order Streamlined Communication and Management : With a single PO, there’s one main point of contact and fewer layers of coordination, making it easier to maintain clarity and avoid misunderstandings. Reduced Administrative Overhead : Managing multiple POs can create administrative challenges, from contract negotiation to handling project milestones and payments. A single contract reduces the complexity. Accountability : A single vendor is accountable for the entire project, meaning they are responsible for both the high-level planning and the detailed execution. This can lead to better overall project alignment and fewer disputes over scope or responsibility. With a well-developed scope, you likely will have structured your commercial terms to be mostly “fixed fee”, with some exceptions (typically commissioning and startup support are performed on a “time and expense” basis). This transfers risk to the seller, but you are likely to pay marginally more for that risk reduction than you would otherwise by managing several vendors through multiple purchase orders. Benefits of Multiple Purchase Orders Specialization and Expertise : By issuing separate POs for functional specification, configuration, construction, and fabrication, clients can hire specialized organizations with the expertise to excel in each area. This can lead to higher-quality outputs for each phase of the project. Greater Control : Multiple POs give the client more control over the contracting process and each project's stage. For organizations that want tight oversight or are managing a particularly complex or high-risk control system migration, this level of control can help mitigate potential risks. If your organization has the skills and bandwidth to manage multiple vendors, and with a well-defined scope, you may save money by assuming the coordination efforts and associated project risk. Flexibility in Vendor Selection : When using several purchase orders, the client can select different vendors based on their strengths and price points for specific tasks. Deciding What’s Right for Your Control System Migration Project The decision between one purchase order or several is often determined by the company’s internal resources and its desired level of control. Some companies prefer the simplicity and efficiency of a single purchase order, especially if they have limited resources for managing multiple vendors. Others, particularly those with more complex projects or specific performance requirements, may prefer to split the project into smaller parts, ensuring they have direct control over each critical phase. Think Through Getting Keys to Your New System When planning a control system migration, it is natural for an organization to focus on the design, configuration, and installation phases. However, it’s equally important to think through what happens when the project is complete and the “ keys ” to the new system are handed over. This handoff represents not only the culmination of the technical work but also the point where the organization takes full responsibility for operating and maintaining the system or has appropriately arranged for contracted maintenance support. Beyond Design and Configuration The process of " getting the keys " involves much more than simply having a control system delivered and installed. Organizations must consider the resources needed for successful cutover, site testing, startup, and ongoing support once the project is complete. It’s not enough to just focus on the technical aspects leading up to the handover. Teams must think ahead about the operational and maintenance requirements once the vendor steps back. In many cases, a company might not have the internal resources or expertise to fully support the new system, especially if it's significantly different from what was in place before. This lack of resources has become more common, which makes planning for post-handover support essential. Planning for Post-Commissioning Support One important consideration is whether your organization will need follow-on support contracts. Although the system may be handed over in a fully operational state, it’s important to have a plan in place for ongoing maintenance and troubleshooting. For many organizations, this means working with the vendor to establish a support contract that extends beyond the handover period. In some cases, the first year of support can be capitalized as part of the control system migration project itself. This can be a significant advantage, as capitalizing the support allows organizations to fund it through the project’s capital budget rather than requiring additional operating expenses after the project is complete. However, it’s important to consider this early in the planning process. If your organization decides that a support contract is needed, this needs to be factored into the overall project budget and submitted for capital approval before the project begins. Early involvement by your company’s accounting department may prevent difficult discussions later regarding capitalizing or expensing support contracts. Whether it's planning for site testing, securing support contracts, or ensuring proper training, the handoff should be seen as the start of ownership rather than the end of the project. This proactive approach will set the stage for sustained success well beyond the initial migration. Defining System Specification and Functional Specification With any control system migration project, there are two subsets of the overall procurement specification — the system specification and the functional specification. These two areas serve distinct purposes and must be clearly defined to ensure a successful control system migration. The terms for these project documents vary in name and format, but the content is critically important. System Specification: Defining the Hardware and Software Requirements The system specification, sometimes referred to as the hardware specification, focuses on the technical aspects of the control system — specifically, what hardware and software are required to meet the control system migration project’s goals. This specification details the necessary components, such as controllers, servers, communication networks, and software platforms, ensuring that the system will meet the operational and performance requirements laid out by the client. The development of the system specification is usually a more straightforward process compared to the functional specification. Owners can rely heavily on the expertise of their chosen OEMs or systems integrators, as they are familiar with the capabilities of the control platforms they work with. Although not as necessary as with the functional specification aspect, it is still beneficial for a client to work with the vendor to ensure that the specification aligns with the project’s overall objectives and operational constraints. Functional Specification: Defining What the System Needs to Do The functional specification, on the other hand, focuses on the operational requirements of the system — what it must do to meet the company’s needs . A functional specification document answers critical questions about how the system should behave, how processes will be controlled, and how new or existing functionalities will be managed within the system. For example, if the project involves a legacy system upgrade, the functional specification must outline what the system currently does and any additional functionalities that the new system needs to perform. To a greater extent than the system specification, the development of the functional specification requires collaboration between the owner and the vendor. It should be noted however, that vendors and systems integrators, while experts in control systems and platforms, are not typically process experts. They may have extensive knowledge of the systems they engineer, but they may not have the same depth of understanding about the specific chemical or mechanical processes that the system must control. This is why functional specification development requires input from both parties. The client, who has a thorough understanding of the processes involved, must work closely with the vendor to ensure that the control narratives and operational requirements are fully captured. This collaboration is critical to avoid misunderstandings or gaps in the system’s functionality, which could lead to delays or operational issues during startup. Exceptions do exist, so you may find an OEM or a systems integrator with deep process knowledge of your industry. If so, consider yourself fortunate, as functional specification development is often an area where a dearth of owner resources or expertise can bog down the progress and result in schedule delays, or worse, improperly specified functional requirements. System and functional specifications are fundamental to the success of a control system migration project. While the system specification focuses on the hardware and software requirements, the functional specification defines how the system will operate and meet the owner's needs. Developing these specifications requires a balance between technical expertise and process knowledge, with close collaboration between the owner and vendor. By selecting a vendor that understands both the platforms and the importance of collaboration, owners can ensure a smoother, successful migration process. Understanding the “As-Is” State of a System One of the more challenging elements of a control system migration is documenting the current, or “ as-is ” state of the system — both the physical and the logical (the programming) . The accuracy of the existing system’s documentation impacts the success of the migration process, particularly during detail design and implementation. Unfortunately, for systems that have been in place for decades, such documentation may be incomplete, outdated, or exist only in the form of internal team knowledge passed down informally within the organization. Project teams and vendors should have a clear understanding of the physical layout, wiring, and system configuration before beginning any detailed design work. This includes capturing details such as I/O points, control panels, network architecture, and wiring diagrams. In some cases, the hardware may have undergone ad-hoc modifications over the years that were never formally documented, further complicating the process. The configuration (programming) of the system must also be documented, so that all parties can understand how the process is currently controlled, even if significant changes are planned. For these reasons, documenting the as-is state of the hardware and software must happen during the Front-End Loading (FEL) phase. Doing so helps ensure that the team has a solid foundation to work from when transitioning to the new system. The risk of skipping this step, or relying on incomplete documentation, is that errors will arise during cutover — especially during time-critical turnarounds — which can lead to expensive delays or operational disruptions. Options for Capturing the As-Is State Companies must make a decision early in the project about how to approach capturing the as-is state. If the system documentation is poorly maintained, as is often the case with older systems, the owner needs to assess whether they have the internal resources and expertise to update and complete the documentation themselves. This effort can be time-consuming and requires a deep understanding of both the process and the control system architecture. Alternatively, the owner may choose to outsource this work to third-party vendors who specialize in control system migrations. Vendor Migration Options The process of evaluating vendor migration options involves not only selecting the right platform (a vendor may offer several variations), but also defining the stages of migration and determining how much flexibility or structure you want to allow in the vendor proposals. The goal is to ensure that vendors understand the scope of the project and are equipped to meet both your technical and operational needs. Platform Choices: Balancing Cost and Capability The choice of platform for your control system migration is one that will impact the cost, capability, and future flexibility of the system. There is a wide range of options, from more affordable, bare-bones platforms to premium, highly capable systems with extensive features and flexibility. By clearly defining your platform requirements, you can guide vendors to propose solutions that meet both your budgetary and operational needs. However, it’s important to strike a balance — although low-cost solutions may be attractive, they may not offer the long-term benefits or reliability needed for your specific industry. Staging the Migration Process Another important consideration is determining the stages of the migration process. Operators should define an execution strategy that outlines the sequence of steps: which parts of the system will be migrated first, second, third, and so on. This approach allows you to ensure a smooth transition and minimize disruptions during the migration. If vendors aren’t provided with enough detail about how the migration will unfold, they may make assumptions that lead to misaligned or faulty bids that may not be executable if the migration stages and sequence aren’t properly communicated. Providing Flexibility for Vendors While some companies may know exactly what they need and dictate a rigid scope, others may want to give vendors the flexibility to propose creative solutions or cost-saving ideas. In these cases, it’s important to structure the procurement specifications to allow for both a base bid and optional upgrades or alternative strategies. For example, the base bid would cover the minimum requirements, while vendors could offer additional features or enhancements as options. This approach ensures that vendors meet the project’s essential needs but also allows room for innovation, enabling the owner to consider creative or cost-effective solutions that may not have been previously identified. Choosing the right vendor migration options involves a balance between defining project requirements, an execution sequence that aligns with business needs, and allowing vendors the flexibility to propose creative solutions. Owners need to determine the most appropriate platform based on budget, capability, operational constraints (allowed downtime for migration activities), and future needs, while also structuring the procurement specifications to allow for both base bids and optional enhancements. By clearly defining the stages of migration and establishing guidelines for vendor proposals, owners can avoid the pitfalls of inconsistent or inexecutable bids and ensure a smoother, more predictable migration process. OEM vs. Systems Integrator Another decision companies face with any control system migration project where a “buy” decision has been made is whether to partner with an Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) or a systems integrator (SI) to perform the implementation. This decision depends on several factors, including the size and complexity of the project, budget constraints, and the need for local versus global availability. Working with an OEM OEMs are the original providers of the hardware and software platforms running the vast majority of the world’s automated control systems. These companies have deep knowledge of their products and can provide comprehensive support for implementing and configuring their systems. However, partnering with an OEM often comes with higher costs. Large OEMs typically have higher hourly labor rates, and their teams may not be located locally, which can add travel expenses to the project. Additionally, OEMs are sometimes more focused on larger, high-value projects, and they may not find smaller migration projects as attractive. This means that for smaller projects, you might not receive the same level of attention or priority from the OEM. Despite these potential downsides, the advantage of working with an OEM is the assurance that you’re working with the team that knows the platform inside and out. They can often provide direct access to new features, updates, and the highest levels of technical support, which can be critical for highly complex or high-risk projects. Additionally, if your company is taking on migrations as a strategic business initiative at multiple sites concurrently, an OEM partnership, with its deep resources, may make the most sense. Working with a Systems Integrator Alternatively, many organizations choose to partner with a systems integrator (SI) for their control system migration projects. SIs are typically smaller, more localized or regional firms that specialize in implementing and integrating control system platforms, often in partnership with one or more OEMs. They can provide a more cost-effective option, particularly for small to mid-sized projects, as their labor rates tend to be lower than those of the large OEMs. One key benefit of working with a systems integrator is their proximity. A local or regional SI can offer more hands-on, timely support throughout the migration process. They are also likely to be more flexible and responsive to smaller projects, which might not be a priority for the OEM. Additionally, because they maintain relationships with the OEM, they can often provide the necessary expertise while still offering a more personalized and cost-effective service. It’s also important to consider the relationship that an SI has with the OEM. Many SIs have deep experience with specific platforms and work closely with the OEMs to ensure they are up to date on the latest technologies and standards. This allows them to act as an extension of the OEM’s expertise, but with the added benefit of being more focused on your specific needs. The Takeaway | Control System Migration Procurement Specification & Vendor Selection Control system migrations are complex, multifaceted projects that require careful planning, strategic decision-making, and collaboration with the right partners. From deciding whether to manage tasks in-house or outsource to engineering experts, to developing well-written procurement specifications, choosing between single or multiple purchase orders, and selecting the right vendor migration options, every decision impacts the project’s chances of success. Organizations must carefully consider their internal resources, the complexity of the system, and their long-term operational needs to determine the best approach. By taking the time to document the "as-is" state, clearly define system and functional specifications, and engage the right vendors — whether OEMs or systems integrators — companies can navigate the challenges of control system migrations effectively. The key to success lies in thorough preparation, informed vendor selection, and strategic execution to ensure a smooth transition and sustainable outcomes.
- Leverage Unplanned Shutdowns to Enhance Safety Testing | ChemicalProcessing.com
Updated June 2026 - Discover how to leverage unplanned shutdowns to facilitate proof testing of safety instrumented functions, improving safety protocols and minimizing downtime. This article explores the following topics: Click here to read the full article on ChemicalProcessing.com Utilizing unplanned shutdowns for safety instrumented function (SIF) proof testing Reducing maintenance frequency by leveraging these events as safety tests Ensuring regulatory compliance through proper documentation and test validation Applying software tools and data analytics to optimize safety testing Exploring future trends like AI and automation in safety management Read the full article here: Leverage Unplanned Shutdowns to Enhance Safety Testing - ChemicalProcessing.com
- ISS Source - Functional Safety Assessment Stage 1 Can Discover Critical Flaws Early
Updated June 2026 - Imagine discovering a critical flaw in your safety system design before your plant goes operational. This scenario, while nerve-wracking, underscores the importance of early intervention in the design phase. This article explores the following topics: Click here to read the full article on ISSSource.com How FSA Stage 1 can discover critical flaws early How FSA Stage 1 can reduce incidents The process steps for FSA Stage 1 How FSA Stage 1 can help prevent costly fixes How FSA Stage 1 can help prevent unknown renewable energy risks Read the full article here: Functional Safety Assessment Stage 1 can Discover Critical Flaws Early (ISSSource.com)
- Enhancing Process Safety: Five Tips to Build a Better System
Reports of accidental releases involving hazardous chemicals at fixed facilities in the US reached all-time highs during the 2023 fiscal year. For these reasons and others, process safety improvements are top of mind in the industrial sector. So how can organizations prioritize limited resources, people-power, and time to take action? This article explores the following topics: Rising Incidents and the Importance of Safety : Reports of process safety incidents have been increasing, with a 51% rise in reportable incidents in 2023, including significant increases in injuries (11%) and deaths (78%), highlighting the urgent need for improved process safety practices. Leadership Commitment : Strong leadership is essential for a robust process safety culture. Senior management must prioritize safety over productivity, dedicating resources, time, and direction to safety initiatives to avoid incidents that could cause serious harm and financial losses. Real-World Data Application : Organizations should implement a structured approach like the PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) cycle to assess process safety systems, execute improvements, and continuously monitor outcomes using real-world data to drive safety progress. Employee Empowerment : Engaging and empowering employees at all levels, especially those interested in becoming subject matter experts (SMEs), fosters a more inclusive safety culture. Educating staff on process safety can bridge knowledge gaps and accelerate improvement efforts. Start Small for Bigger Wins : Focusing on smaller, more manageable process safety improvements can lead to early successes. These wins help organizations build momentum and prepare for tackling more complex safety challenges in the future. Continuous Improvement (CI) System : Utilizing continuous improvement methodologies, like Kaizen and Lean Manufacturing, helps organizations make incremental changes that enhance safety and operational efficiency. Choosing a suitable CI approach and sticking with it is key to long-term success. Focus on Culture : A high-performing process safety program relies on a culture of continuous improvement, employee engagement, and early wins. Starting small and sustaining progress is critical to enhancing both safety and overall operational performance. by Judith Leslie, CFSE, CSP, CCPSC , senior principal specialist with aeSolutions . Read the full article here: Enhancing Process Safety: Five Tips to Build a Better System (Powderbulksolids.com)
- FSA Stage 2: Evaluating the Safety Instrumented System (SIS) Readiness for Field Installation
Understanding FSA Stage 2 Continuing from part one of our Functional Safety Assessment (FSA) series , FSA Stage 2 is a critical checkpoint after design and engineering of the Safety Instrumented System (SIS). At this pre-installation stage, the FSA team assesses that the SIS will perform reliably once operational. It means ensuring that the design and engineering of the SIS meet the requirements as defined in the Safety Requirements Specification (SRS) developed during earlier phases of the SIS safety life cycle as described in the process industry consensus ISA / IEC 61511 standard. According to the ISA / IEC 61511 standard, it is recommended to perform an FSA Stage 2 after the SIS has been designed and factory acceptance tested . Conducting a thorough FSA Stage 2 ensures that potential safety issues are identified and resolved before the SIS is operational, preventing costly changes, rework, and unexpected project delays. What are the Goals of FSA Stage 2? The success of any SIS hinges on whether the design makes sense for real-world considerations. During FSA Stage 2, every component of the SIS goes through rigorous verification and testing for any field installation problems. This stage verifies compliance with the requirements as defined in the SRS while also identifying potential issues that could compromise safety. Table 1: What FSA Stage 2 Accomplishes Design Verification Implementation Review Prepare for Installation Confirm that the SIS design meets the requirements as defined in the SRS Assess the SIS hardware and software components to ensure they are correctly designed and engineered for field installation Establish a strong foundation for the successful execution of subsequent phases of the SIS safety life cycle. What is the FSA Stage 2 Process? At the heart of every FSA Stage 2 is a thorough review of the SIS design and engineering. This involves evaluating the SIS logic solver(s), input/output (I/O) modules, communication system(s), control panel(s), and other critical components, including field instrumentation, to ensure they meet the design specifications provided in the SRS. The assessment also verifies that the SIS components are configured to fulfill their intended Safety Instrumented Functions (SIFs). Any discrepancies or gaps are identified and corrected before they can impact the SIS performance. A common misconception is that FSA Stage 2 can serve as a substitute for Factory Acceptance Testing (FAT) , where the SIS logic solver(s) hardware and software are tested in a controlled environment prior to field installation. In reality, they are complementary processes that work together to ensure system reliability. FAT tests the SIS logic solver(s) hardware and software, while FSA Stage 2 provides an independent assessment of these tests, ensuring the system is robust, meets all requirements, and is ready for the field installation. Proper documentation is the backbone of an effective FSA. In addition to reviewing the output of the FSA Stage 1, the FSA Stage 2 will review the documentation developed during the SIS design and engineering. One of the most important aspects of the FSA Stage 2 is to confirm all the findings from the FSA Stage 1 are addressed. By verifying that all findings from previous stages are documented and addressed, teams can maintain continuity and avoid costly delays ensuring that the SIS evolves smoothly from design to implementation and beyond. What is the Stakeholder Involvement for an FSA Stage 2? FSA Stage 2 is a team effort, and results are highly dependent on the involvement of key personnel including the following essential roles: Table 2: Roles & Responsibilities Role Responsibilities PHA and LOPA Leader Ensures that the outcomes of the hazard and risk assessments are accurately reflected in the SIS design and engineering. Operations Representative Verifies the practicality and effectiveness of their operational processes implemented in the SIS design and engineering. Maintenance Representative Assesses the maintainability and testability of the SIS, ensuring that future maintenance needs are considered during the SIS design and engineering. SIS Engineer Oversees the technical aspects of the SIS, ensuring that all components meet the required specifications and performance standards provided in the SRS. FSA Stage 2 | An aeSolutions Case Study Recently, aeSolutions conducted an FSA for a fired equipment modernization program which involved multiple thermal oxidizers/incinerators. The project faced several challenges, including inconsistent safety requirements and the complex integration of new SIS components with the existing systems. By conducting a thorough FSA Stage 2, the team identified and corrected design flaws early, preventing potential safety hazards and ensuring the SIS met updated regulatory standards and design requirements. The FSA Stage 2 process included a comprehensive review of the SIS design and engineering documentation including the FAT records and an independent assessment to ensure the new SIS equipment was ready for the field installation. The lessons learned from the first thermal oxidizer were applied to subsequent fired equipment, streamlining the FSA process and reducing overall project costs. This proactive approach not only enhanced safety but also fostered collaboration among the project engineering, operations, and maintenance teams, contributing to a more robust and reliable SIS. The success of this project demonstrated the value of performing a meticulous FSA Stage 2, particularly in complex modernization efforts. The insights gained have been integrated into the company’s standard procedures for future projects, ensuring that similar initiatives can be managed more efficiently while maintaining the highest safety standards. The Takeaway Per the ISA / IEC 61511 standard, FSAs provide a five-stage, evidence-based investigation to judge the functional safety achieved by one or more SIS and/or other protection layers. FSA Stage 2 is the critical step in ensuring that the SIS is ready for field installation. By thoroughly verifying the SIS design and engineering, FSA Stage 2 helps to identify and address potential issues before they escalate into costly rework and project delays. It safeguards the integrity of the SIS, verifying that all components meet safety standards and are configured for optimal performance. This stage supports bridging the gap between design and construction, ensuring that all SIS components are aligned with safety requirements — readying them for the field installation. As organizations continue to adopt more complex and integrated systems, the value of a thorough FSA Stage 2 becomes even more critical — laying the groundwork for safer, more efficient, and ultimately more successful projects. Be sure to check out the next blog in our FSA series that discusses how an FSA Stage 3 confirms your Safety Instrumented System (SIS) is ready for operational use .
- T-shirts, Polos, and Flannels, oh my! Making Casual Day Work Across the Country
In the world of employment policies, there is a magical two-word phrase that suddenly changes one key policy (the infamous dress code) into something completely different: “casual day.” The casual day is a specific time when employees are allowed, and sometimes encouraged, to dress in a more casual, relaxed, and laidback style than the normal dress code calls for, and is generally seen as a fun way to break from the norm. At aeSolutions, we have our own version of the casual day every Friday. On these days, employees who aren’t meeting with clients or working at a job site may wear jeans and a more casual shirt to the office. Occasionally, this can lead to some funny discoveries about an employee’s fashion sense, or propensity to go clothes shopping at the same stores (check out the picture of Ken and Josh, who came in as accidental twins a few weeks ago!), but overall it’s appreciated by everyone as a way to relax as we close out another fast-paced week. This tradition started in our Greenville, SC headquarters, but as the company has grown and expanded into Texas, Alaska, and beyond, it’s been fascinating to watch how our “dress down” Fridays have been incorporated into each office. Our Greenville office, which has an average January temperature of about 50 degrees, is where you’ll usually see the most t-shirts year-round. During the college football season, all the shirts in the office seem to change color at the same time, and it’s not uncommon to see clusters of Clemson Orange or University of SC Garnet & Black take over some of our conference rooms. Meanwhile, over in our Houston office, polo shirts (the unofficial uniform of engineers everywhere) tend to come out in full force when Friday rolls around. Given the heat, we’ve recently even incorporated a system where employees can contribute to fundraising efforts for the Leukemia & Lymphoma Society in order to earn a “shorts day” – which is much appreciated in the middle of summer! The Anchorage office has its own unique take on the day. Some of our Anchorage staff actually start the week at the exact opposite end of the spectrum, wearing ties on Monday (not required by our dress code!) This makes the eventual “dress down” on Friday all the more visible. For most of the year, these days are accompanied by a sea of flannel taking over the office. For a rare handful of weeks in the summer the odd short-sleeved shirt will make an appearance, but those usually disappear before September and the season’s first snow. Regardless of the office you’re in, our casual Friday has become an important part of the aeSolutions culture. We have fun with it and get to show off what snazzy dressers we can be while staying focused on continuously improving the process safety performance of our clients. If you’re interested in exploring whether aeSolutions is the right fit for you, you can view our open positions at www.aesolutions.com/careers. ---------------------- aeSolutions Corporate Culture: https://www.aesolutions.com/corporate-responsibility Individual Employee Spotlights: https://www.aesolutions.com/employee-spotlight
- aeSolutions to Participate in AIChE 2024 Center for Hydrogen Safety Americas Conference
Company to Serve as 2024 Conference Bronze Sponsor LAS VEGAS – May 17, 2024 – aeSolutions, a consulting, engineering and systems integration company that provides industrial process safety and automation products and services, today announced that the company will be presenting at the AIChE 2024 Center for Hydrogen Safety Americas Conference. The conference will be held at the Hampton Inn Tropicana in Las Vegas, Nevada, from May 21 - 23, 2024. Presented by the Center for Hydrogen Safety, the conference brings together attendees from academia, industry, and government to discuss applied hydrogen safety topics, provide space for collaboration, and to offer attendees training and educational opportunities. In attendance from aeSolutions will be VP of Solution Development Ken Whittle and Senior Project Manager Warren Johnson, PE, PMP, who will be serving as the company’s spokespersons and speaking to attendees about aeSolutions’ extensive experience in hydrogen manufacturing and hydrogen safety practices. Additionally, aeSolutions will act as a Bronze sponsor for the conference. WHAT: AIChE 2024 Center for Hydrogen Safety Americas Conference WHO: aeSolutions VP of Solution Development Ken Whittle and Senior Project Manager Warren Johnson, PE, PMP WHERE: Hampton Inn Tropicana, Las Vegas, Nevada WHEN: May 21 - 23, 2024 REGISTRATION: https://www.aiche.org/chs/conferences/center-hydrogen-safety-conference/2024/registration-info To arrange a meeting with a member of the aeSolutions team, contact info@aesolutions.com. About aeSolutions In business since 1998, aeSolutions is a consulting, engineering, and systems integration company that provides industrial process safety and automation products and services. They specialize in helping industrial clients achieve their risk management and operational excellence goals through expertise in process safety, combustion control and safeguarding, safety instrumented systems, control system design and integration, alarm management, and related operations and integrity management systems. For more information, visit www.aesolutions.com. Media Contact Kari Ritacco RedIron Public Relations for aeSolutions kari@redironpr.com
- aeSolutions Engages with Talent at Recent Career Fair
aeSolutions recently participated in the Clemson Spring 2024 Career Fair, geared toward STEM graduates. It was an invaluable opportunity for us to engage with talented individuals eager to embark on a career in engineering. We are incredibly grateful for the chance to connect with prospective candidates and showcase what makes aeSolutions an exceptional place to pursue your full potential. Attending career fairs is not just about finding immediate hires; it's about cultivating relationships with future members of the workforce, whether they work for aeSolutions, or with aeSolutions as business partners or even clients. These events provide us with a platform to interact with students and professionals who possess the skills and passion that align with our core values of being Results-Driven, Inclusive, and Relentless. Moreover, these events allow us to stay current with emerging trends in the industry and gain insights into the aspirations of the next generation of engineers. At aeSolutions we prioritize hiring individuals with diverse backgrounds and skill sets to drive innovation and problem-solving. We actively seek candidates majoring in fields such as Chemical Engineering, Mechanical Engineering, and Electrical Engineering, as these disciplines are directly applicable to our work in Process Safety and Automation. Whether it's performing complex risk analysis studies, designing safety systems, or programming and implementing cutting-edge automation solutions, we believe in harnessing the expertise of multidisciplinary teams to deliver exceptional results. We are especially thankful for our aeSolutions employees who dedicated their time and effort to represent our company at the career fair. Their enthusiasm, professionalism, and commitment to showcasing our company culture and opportunities were truly commendable! If you're someone looking to kickstart or advance your career in engineering, we invite you to explore opportunities with us. Whether you're a recent graduate or an experienced professional, we welcome individuals who are eager to improve industry by guiding our clients to increasingly resilient operations and safety communities. You can view our latest job openings at www.aesolutions.com/careers, or submit your resume directly to one of our recruiters at resumes@aesolutions.com.
- aeSolutions to Exhibit at the 2022 South Carolina Manufacturing Conference and Expo
Company Will Showcase New Machinery Safety Line of Service Greenville, SC – October 19, 2022 – aeSolutions, a consulting, engineering and systems integration company that provides industrial process safety and automation products and services, today announced that the company will be exhibiting at the 2022 South Carolina Manufacturing Expo. The Conference and Expo will take place at the Greenville Convention Center in Greenville, South Carolina from November 3 - 4. With more than 3,000 attendees each year, the conference is one of the largest manufacturing events in the Southeast, and provides manufacturing professionals from across the region the opportunity to discuss the latest manufacturing trends and topics, share their visions, and to become inspired by and immersed in manufacturing culture. At this year’s event aeSolutions will be showcasing its new Machinery Safety Line of Service, which aims to reduce injuries associated with human-machine interaction and improve overall plant value while achieving compliance with machinery safety standards. Experts from aeSolutions will be available to discuss your machinery safety needs. WHAT: 2022 South Carolina Manufacturing Expo WHERE: Greenville Convention Center, Greenville, SC Booth # 246 WHEN: November 3 - 4, 2022 REGISTRATION: https://scmanufacturingconference.com/attendee-registration/ To arrange a meeting with a member of the aeSolutions team at the Expo, contact info@aesolutions.com. About aeSolutions In business since 1998, aeSolutions is a consulting, engineering, and systems integration company that provides industrial process safety and automation products and services. They specialize in helping industrial clients achieve their risk management and operational excellence goals through expertise in process safety, combustion control and safeguarding, safety instrumented systems, control system design and integration, alarm management, and related operations and integrity management systems. For more information, visit www.aesolutions.com. Media Contact RedIron PR for aeSolutions kari@redironpr.com
- aeSolutions Announces Appointment of David Ivester as Senior Vice President of Marketing and Sales
Industry Veteran to Focus on Client Success and Growing the Company’s Portfolio Greenville, SC –January 17, 2024– aeSolutions, a consulting, engineering, and systems integration company, today announced the appointment of David Ivester to the position of senior vice president for Sales and Marketing. Ivester will serve on the senior leadership team, where he will head the company’s sales strategy and efforts. “We could not have asked for a better candidate for our sales leader position than David. He is an innovative thinker and problem solver, and has the right market experience,” said aeSolutions President Ken O’Malley. “Most importantly, he is an ideal cultural fit for our organization. Through his collaborative approach, he will help us to refocus on what our clients really need from us.” In his new role as senior vice president, Ivester will provide organizational leadership to help drive the growth of the company’s portfolio. Prior to joining aeSolutions, Ivester accumulated more than 30 years of experience in a variety of leadership positions in sales and marketing in the process automation space. During his previous tenure at Emerson, Ivester held a range of roles, from sales representative to vice president of Global Accounts. In his most recent role at Emerson, his responsibilities included leading a billion-dollar revenue-generating team and managing capital project investments. “From the very beginning of my conversations with aeSolutions about joining the company, I knew I aligned with the company’s focus on client success and employee development. It’s a good fit from a values perspective, and I am also really excited about working in a smaller company with quick decision-making cycles,” said Ivester. “I have a passion for developing long-term, mutually beneficial relationships and I’ve spent a significant portion of my career in the strategic account management segment of sales. My record of hiring and developing talent in my previous role is one of the things I’ve been most proud of. I’m thrilled for this new challenge, and I look forward to applying my knowledge and skills as the company looks to the future.” About aeSolutions In business since 1998, aeSolutions is a consulting, engineering, and systems integration company that provides industrial process safety and automation products and services. They specialize in helping industrial clients achieve their risk management and operational excellence goals through expertise in process safety, combustion control and safeguarding, safety instrumented systems, control system design and integration, alarm management, and related operations and integrity management systems. For more information, visit www.aesolutions.com. Media Contact RedIron PR for aeSolutions kari@redironpr.com
- aeSolutions' Year of Outstanding Growth and Client Retention
Company to Focus on Expansion and Core Expertise in 2022 Greenville, SC – February 23, 2022 –aeSolutions, a consulting, engineering, and systems integration company that provides industrial process safety and automation products and services, today announced company milestones achieved and overall performance for 2021. The company’s significant achievements included outstanding client retention, several key hires to help propel the company into the future, and the release of its newest offering, aeAlarm™. “In looking back at 2021, aeSolutions emerged smarter, stronger, more focused and even better positioned to serve our clients and partners,” said Ken O’Malley, president of aeSolutions. “aeSolutions remains unparalleled in the industry when it comes to helping industrial clients achieve their risk management and operational excellence goals through our expertise in integrating process safety and automation. Our adaptability and capacity to pivot have demonstrated to our clients that we are a trusted partner and service provider, and they can rely on us to offer continuity and excellence even in difficult times. In a year of continued challenges, aeSolutions enjoyed significant repeat business from 72% of its existing clients, a 3% increase over 2020. Furthermore, 43% of the company’s business came from new clients. Over the past two decades, aeSolutions has focused on growing a solid technical team and delivering resilient solutions to industries’ toughest challenges. To address both, the company has begun offering its clients Front End Loading (FEL) conceptual design services that integrate the expertise of all of its service lines rather than aligning under individual solution silos. aeSolutions has endeavored to streamline its product offerings by organizing around these market-facing teams, which has also meant developing strategic plans and raising the bar on project execution and delivery expertise. As a result, aeSolutions’ clients are better equipped to select the optimum design options for their capital projects. O’Malley went on to add, “We have seen an uptick in clients seeking our support for projects that had been put on hold, as well as an increase in clients looking to us to bolster their reduced staff and take broader ownership of projects that would have been typically executed in-house. We are excited to continue strengthening relationships with our current clients and look forward to building relationships with the new.” As the pandemic continued into 2021, aeSolutions remained committed to hiring and developing the best talent, regardless of location; as such, the company continues to offer opportunities to work remotely. Additionally, the firm restarted its intern program and initiated the Rapid Skills Development program, designed to accelerate the process by which staff members who are early in their career become engaged in project work. Key Personnel Appointments The business added several key hires during 2021. Ben Krisher, Human Resources Director: A Human Resources (HR) expert with more than a decade’s worth of experience. At aeSolutions, he manages a high-performing team of HR professionals across the entire company. He specializes in finding and hiring the best technical talent available in the industrial process safety, combustion, and automation fields. Laura Ankrom, Vice President of Process Safety: An aeSolutions veteran with more than 11 years at the company and over 25 years of experience in the process safety and risk management field, including significant involvement in the Occupational Safety and Health Administration Process Safety Management and the United States Environmental Protection Agency Risk Management Program compliance. Laura specializes in and provides technical support in the rollout, implementation, training, and auditing of global and site level process safety and risk management systems and support corporate management systems and leadership development. Roland Stock - Manager of Projects: A specialist in project management with nearly 20 years of experience planning and managing engineering, fabrication, and construction projects focusing on quality, cost containment, adherence to defined scope, and on-time delivery. Roland brings proven leadership and management experience in helping to motivate teams for successful project delivery. aeSolutions Launches Proprietary aeAlarm™ Rationalization Tool In response to a growing market need, aeAlarm was created to support the alarm rationalization process by providing a clear and concise approach to critical alarm documentation. aeAlarm is a control system platform agnostic and is adaptable across all industrial sectors. It is effective for projects of all types and sizes, including small project rationalizations and large site-wide efforts. Additionally, the tool creates a platform to compile process safety information and generates customized reports and tables to expedite data tracking for site-specific Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). Plans for 2022 Heading into the coming year, aeSolutions will continue to strengthen its position as a valued partner to the world’s process manufacturers as they seek to conduct smarter, more resilient industrial operations and contribute to safer communities. To accomplish that, the firm will embrace and expand its renewed emphasis on core consulting and engineering expertise and focus on the growth and expansion of its core business of providing industrial markets with resilient solutions that integrate process safety and automation. The goals for the company will include significant growth in headcount across all expertise areas in the first six months of the year and to continue to foster a culture and expectation of continual professional and personal growth. Through the development of the company and its stakeholders, aeSolutions aspires to enhance the way its stakeholders think about the relationship between customer and supplier, to advance the understanding that it is a relationship built on trust, and to have the embodiment of those ideals result in an excellent experience for the customer. About aeSolutions In business since 1998, aeSolutions is a consulting, engineering, and systems integration company that provides industrial process safety and automation products and services. They specialize in helping industrial clients achieve their risk management and operational excellence goals through expertise in process safety, combustion control and safeguarding, safety instrumented systems, control system design and integration, alarm management, and related operations and integrity management systems. For more information, visit www.aesolutions.com. Media Contact Kari Walker for aeSolutions Kari@redironpr.com @KariWalkerPR "Industrial Process Safety and Automation Company aeSolutions Achieves Year of Outstanding Growth and Client Retention"
- Achieving on-stream control room relocations : Control Engineering
A natural gas processing and compression facility control rooms had to relocate, which caused many challenges in an application with many potential hazards during the process. Project included control panel upgrades, communication digitalization and moving process control and process safety systems. Control room relocation insights Control room, process control system migration project challenges E-stop migration, process isolation safety complications Project lessons learned: System integration project management Six steps for project success included control system, safety system cutover, factory acceptance test, control panel upgrade Project results: Project management, standardization, control panels Lessons for future projects: Front-end loading, codes and standards by Ted Hoffman, PE, senior project development engineer; Charles Mills, automation control specialist, both with aeSolutions. Edited by Chris Vavra, web content manager, CFE Media and Technology. Read the full article here: Achieving on-stream control room relocations (controleng.com)












